Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Women's Well Sisterhood Circle's avatar

Reading Jen Hyde's anniversary essay on her POI diagnosis at 39 — the Japanese word for menopause translates to "renewal of energy," and she's living it. A few clinical notes in the comments, but the essay itself is the thing.

Women's Well Sisterhood Circle's avatar

Jen, thank you for writing this. The Konenki frame — renewal of energy — is one I return to often with patients, and you've articulated something I find myself trying to say in clinic all the time: that the diagnosis arriving early can be its own strange gift, because it gives you years to learn what most women only get months to absorb.

A small clinical footnote on the bone density point, because I think it deserves underlining for anyone reading: for women with POI specifically, that baseline DEXA isn't just useful — it's standard of care, and it should be repeated. The trajectory matters more than any single number. The same goes for a lipid panel and, if you can get one, a coronary artery calcium score in your mid-forties. The cardiovascular piece of POI tends to get less airtime than the bone piece, and it shouldn't.

And your instinct on the social media wariness is exactly right. The testosterone conversation is the clearest example — there's a real clinical use case for it in a narrow band of women, and there's a much larger wellness-marketing case that has gotten ahead of the evidence. Jen Gunter is the right person to read on this.

The line that stayed with me most: 'the hard parts don't have to teach you anything.' I'm going to borrow that, with credit, the next time a patient apologizes for not having found the meaning in her symptoms yet. Thank you for it. With love, Amy Maher

No posts

Ready for more?